Guide to Mutual Funds
Comprehensive guide to mutual funds, their structure, fees, and performance
A Brief History of Mutual Funds
Although pooled investing has antecedents in 18th-century Amsterdam, the modern open-end mutual fund took shape in the United States in the 1920s. Rouwenhorst traces early "investment trusts" to the Netherlands and documents the crucial 1924 launch of Massachusetts Investors Trust, the first U.S. open-end fund to continuously issue and redeem shares at prices proportional to the portfolio's intrinsic value (net asset value, or NAV).
Key Regulatory Milestone
The industry's governance framework was cemented in the wake of the 1929 crash with the U.S. Investment Company Act of 1940 ("'40 Act"), which regulates investment companies—including mutual funds—by mandating disclosure, limiting conflicts of interest, and establishing oversight aimed at protecting fund shareholders.
What a Mutual Fund Is—And Why It Exists
A mutual fund is an open-end investment company that issues redeemable shares; investors buy from and redeem back to the fund at the next calculated NAV (so-called "forward pricing"). This structure lets small investors access diversified, professionally managed portfolios with daily liquidity.
Forward Pricing Mechanism
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) explains that mutual funds must sell and redeem at NAV calculated after the order is placed; investors therefore do not know the exact transacted price until the fund strikes NAV after the market close.
Economic Rationale
The economic rationale for mutual funds has been studied extensively. In rational-markets models, active management doesn't systematically beat passive benchmarks net of fees because competition drives expected alpha toward zero; any managerial skill is competed away as fund size grows (decreasing returns to scale), which helps explain why investors still allocate to active funds despite modest average net-of-fee performance.
Industry Scale and Footprint
According to the Investment Company Institute (ICI), the U.S. registered fund complex (mutual funds, ETFs, closed-end funds, and unit investment trusts) managed $39.2 trillion in total net assets at year-end 2024, serving "more than 125 million" U.S. retail investors.
Asset Breakdown (Year-End 2024)
Source: ICI 2025 Fact Book (published May 15, 2025)
Legal and Organizational Structure
The '40 Act sets out the organizational and disclosure framework for investment companies, requiring registration, prospectuses, periodic reporting, board oversight (including independent directors), and policies that minimize conflicts in complex operations.
Key Requirements
- Registration with the SEC
- Detailed prospectuses and periodic reporting
- Board oversight with independent directors
- Conflict of interest policies
How Mutual Funds Operate (Day to Day)
Pricing, Dealing, and Liquidity
SEC investor publications detail that mutual fund orders are executed at the next computed NAV ("forward pricing"), and shares are redeemable—investors can sell back to the fund at that NAV (minus any redemption fees disclosed in the prospectus). This makes liquidity (at daily NAV) a defining feature.
Fees and Expenses
The SEC highlights that ongoing fund expenses—management fees, 12b-1 distribution/service fees where adopted, and other operating costs—are deducted from assets and disclosed as the expense ratio; these reduce investor returns dollar-for-dollar.
- •Management Fees: Compensation for portfolio management
- •12b-1 Fees: Distribution and service fees (if applicable)
- •Operating Costs: Administrative and operational expenses
Portfolio Management and Oversight
A fund's adviser manages the portfolio within the stated objective/strategy, subject to prospectus limits, board oversight, and regulatory reporting. Custody and transfer-agency functions are separated from the adviser to reduce operational risk and conflicts.
What Purposes Mutual Funds Serve for Investors
Diversification and Scale
By pooling assets, funds offer broad diversification and professional management at low per-investor cost. Investors gain access to asset classes (equities, bonds, money market instruments, target-date/lifecycle funds, sectors) that would be hard or expensive to build individually.
Liquidity and Convenience
Open-end funds' redeemability at once-daily NAV simplifies saving programs (e.g., payroll contributions, automatic reinvestment), and transfer agents handle the operational complexity for millions of accounts.
Retirement Savings
While not a pension plan themselves, mutual funds are widely used inside retirement accounts and target-date structures, channeling household savings into capital markets at scale.
Evidence on Performance, Skill, and Fees
The academic literature provides a nuanced picture of mutual fund performance, with several durable findings:
Early Empirical Tests
Jensen's seminal study (1945–1964) found that, after expenses, mutual funds did not exhibit positive alpha on average, an early challenge to the idea of pervasive stock-picking skill.
This foundational work established the empirical framework for evaluating fund performance that continues to be used today.
Risks, Disclosures, and Investor Protection
The '40 Act's regime—registration, periodic reports, custody segregation, board oversight—aims to minimize conflicts and operational risks. SEC materials stress that investors should:
Key Protection Mechanisms
- ✓Focus on prospectus disclosures (objectives, risks, costs)
- ✓Understand that NAV-based liquidity does not immunize against market risk
- ✓Recognize that expenses reduce returns over time
- ✓Custodial segregation and independent transfer agency reduce fraud/operational risk by separating money flows and recordkeeping from portfolio decision-making
Mutual Funds vs. Their Cousins: ETFs and Closed-End Funds
Mutual funds and ETFs share '40 Act lineage but differ in trading and cash-flow mechanics: mutual funds transact once daily at NAV with the fund; ETFs trade intraday on exchanges via creation/redemption by authorized participants—features that affect taxes, trading costs, and investor behavior.
Structural Contrasts
| Feature | Mutual Funds | ETFs | Closed-End Funds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading | Once daily at NAV | Intraday on exchanges | Intraday at market price |
| Share Creation | Continuous | Via authorized participants | Fixed number |
| Premium/Discount | None (trades at NAV) | Minimal (arbitrage) | Common |
| Tax Efficiency | Standard | Enhanced (in-kind) | Standard |
Closed-end funds, by contrast, have exchange-traded shares that may trade at discounts/premiums to NAV and can employ leverage; they are distinct from open-end mutual funds despite common regulatory roots. These structural contrasts inform investor choice depending on liquidity preferences, trading style, and tax considerations.
What's Important to the Genre Today
Scale and Household Reach
With $28.5T in mutual fund assets at year-end 2024 and more than 125M U.S. retail investors participating in registered funds, the vehicle remains central to household finance and retirement saving.
Fee Pressure and Selection
The literature's emphasis on costs—and the mixed evidence on persistent skill—elevates fee awareness and due diligence, echoing SEC investor education.
Active vs. Passive
Research on Active Share and industry concentration underscores that truly differentiated active strategies may add value in specific contexts, but investors must verify that "active" isn't simply expensive closet indexing.
Closing Note on Selection
For investors, mutual funds provide professionally managed diversification and daily NAV liquidity under a robust regulatory regime. The literature counsels realism: average net performance tends to mirror costs; diligent fund selection (strategy fit, authentic activeness, capacity limits, and fees) is key, and prospectus/annual report disclosures—required by the '40 Act and SEC rules—are the primary tools for aligning a fund's design with an investor's objectives and constraints.
Important Disclaimer
This content is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. The author is not a registered investment advisor, certified financial planner, or certified public accountant. Always consult with qualified professionals before making any financial decisions. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Investing involves risk, including potential loss of principal.
The information provided here is based on the author's opinions and experience. Your financial situation is unique, and you should consider your own circumstances before making any financial decisions.
Share This Article
Sources & References
Click on any cited text in the article to jump to its source.